Mon. Nov 16th, 2026

Christmas shoppers have lists to check. This year, the stores themselves are getting checked, too.

Liberty Counsel has released its 2026 Naughty and Nice List, grading retailers on how they acknowledge Christmas in their online seasonal marketing. The question is simple: Does Christmas get a welcome, or does its name disappear behind the holiday sales?

The ratings reflect LC’s website review as of Nov. 11. Here’s where the retailers landed, with brief summaries of the organization’s assessments.

The Nice List

These stores earned a spot on LC’s good side. Some brought plenty of Christmas cheer. Others squeezed into the sleigh.

  • Bass Pro Shops: A Nice List newcomer. That’s a keeper.
  • Barnes & Noble: Turns the page with Merry Christmas gift cards.
  • Bath & Body Works: Christmas mentions require browsing. Follow your nose.
  • Bealls Department Store: Maintains a dedicated Christmas section.
  • Bed Bath & Beyond: Christmas categories furnish its holiday shop.
  • Big Lots: Moves up thanks to its Christmas section.
  • Bronner’s CHRISTmas WONDERLAND: Keeps Christ and the Nativity prominent.
  • Costco: Makes room for Christmas merchandise.
  • Dillard’s: Keeps Christmas in its seasonal offerings.
  • Dollar General: Debuts on the Nice List.
  • Dollar Tree: Another newcomer earning a Christmas gold star.
  • Gabe’s: An older Christmas campaign keeps it aboard.
  • Hallmark: Christmas merchandise earns LC’s approval.
  • Hobby Lobby Stores: Continues openly acknowledging Christmas.
  • The Home Depot: Builds on its Nice List standing.
  • The Incredible Christmas Place: Christmas merchandise matches the name. Whew.
  • JCPenney: Christmas products include Nativity scenes.
  • Kirkland’s: Gives Christmas prominent homepage space.
  • Kohl’s: Christmas offerings keep it in good standing.
  • Lehman’s Hardware: Features Christmas shopping and Nativity items.
  • Lowe’s: Keeps its Nice List spot.
  • Macy’s: Its Christmas shop takes some searching.
  • Menards: Welcomes shoppers with Christmas greetings.
  • Sam’s Club: Christmas merchandise helps renew its membership here.
  • Sears: Maintains an online Christmas section.
  • Staples: Features Christmas cards. Pencil in some cheer.
  • Target: Celebrates its third consecutive Nice List appearance.
  • Walmart: Remains among LC’s Christmas-friendly retailers.

The Naughty List

These retailers missed LC’s Christmas mark. There’s still time to improve next year’s report card.

  • Academy Sports + Outdoors: Christmas wording barely makes the lineup.
  • American Eagle Outfitters: Seasonal gift pages were unavailable.
  • Belk: Slides over from last year’s Nice List.
  • Best Buy: Also loses its Nice List standing.
  • Burlington: Remains here for avoiding Christmas wording.
  • CVS Pharmacy: Christmas is largely missing online.
  • Dick’s Sporting Goods: Christmas avoidance keeps it on this roster.
  • Eddie Bauer: Generic holiday messaging leaves LC cold.
  • Gap Inc.: Christmas gets little acknowledgment, including at Old Navy, Banana Republic and Athleta.
  • H&M: Generic seasonal messaging misses the mark.
  • J. Crew Outfitters: Remains here for sidelining Christmas.
  • Kmart: LC found no online Christmas attention.
  • The Loft: Festive visuals, little Christmas meaning.
  • Lord and Taylor: Celebrates the season without identifying Christmas.
  • Neiman Marcus: Continues earning LC’s seasonal disapproval.
  • Nordstrom: Christmas acknowledgment still falls short.
  • TJ Maxx, Marshalls, HomeGoods, Sierra Trading Co. and Homesense: LC found no overt Christmas references.
  • Walgreens: Christmas barely surfaces in its holiday campaign.

Order Abby Trivett’s New Book, “The Power of Suddenly” on Amazon.com!

A gracious thank-you can encourage a store that celebrates Christmas. A courteous note can tell another why the name matters. Neither requires a scene at the checkout counter.

As we fill our carts, we can also keep Jesus at the center of our own celebrations. The greatest gift arrived in a manger, and no Black Friday bargain will ever top Him.

To view Liberty Counsel’s full list, click here.

James Lasher, a seasoned writer and editor at Charisma Media, combines faith and storytelling with a journalism background from Otterbein University and ministry experience in Guatemala and at the LA Dream Center. A Marine Corps and Air Force veteran, he is the author of The Revelation of Jesus: A Common Man’s Commentary and a contributor to Charisma magazine. For interviews and media inquiries, please contact [email protected].

Leave a Reply

By submitting your comment, you agree to receive occasional emails from [email protected], and its authors, including insights, exclusive content, and special offers. You can unsubscribe at any time. (U.S. residents only.)

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Copy link