Brian Zahnd: ‘Unconditional?’

Posted by



In his book Unconditional?, Brian Zahnd
challenges believers with a “radical call of Jesus to forgiveness.” Using
stories, historical and theological insights, Zahnd, pastor of Word of Life
Church in St. Joseph, Mo., reminds us of the foundation of Christianity.
Although forgiveness is not an easy command to obey, as Christians, we have the
grace to do so—no matter what.

 Featured in The Buzz is an
excerpt from Zahnd’s new insightful book. (Click here to purchase

What does it mean to be a
disciple? If someone were a disciple of the sitar master Ravi Shankar, it would
be assumed that they hoped to learn to play the sitar with great skill. If
someone were a disciple of a kung fu master, it would be assumed that they hope
to eventually master the art of kung fu. So, if we call ourselves disciples of
Jesus, what is it we are trying to learn? What is it that Jesus offers to teach
us when we heed the call to follow Him? 
What is Jesus the master of, which we seek to learn? The answer is
“Life.” Jesus is the master of living well, living rightly, living truly. Jesus
is the master of living a human life as God intended.  And at the center of Jesus’ teaching on how we should live is the
recurring theme of love and forgiveness. 

For those who are serious about
being a disciple of Jesus, serious about learning to live the way He taught,
the Sermon on the Mount is of supreme importance. This is where Jesus sets
forth His radical vision of how we should live. And make no mistake about it;
it is radical—so radical that for much of Christian history, the church has
occupied theologians in finding ways to get around it. Some theologians have
suggested that Jesus never actually expected us to live the Sermon on the
Mount; rather it was a disingenuous teaching to “drive us to grace.” As the
argument goes, in attempting to live the Sermon on the Mount we would find it
simply can’t be done, and then we would look to grace as an alternative to
obeying Christ. Not grace to live the Sermon on the Mount, but grace not to
live it.  This interpretation is pretty
far-fetched, to say the least, but surprisingly common.

Other theologians have
argued that the Sermon on the Mount should be viewed as attitudes of the heart,
but not as commandments to be actually obeyed. So that as long as you have the
attitude of love in your heart, you don’t have to actually go the second mile
or actually turn the other cheek. I suppose this means that when you are
treated unkindly you can retaliate like everyone else, but you are to do so
with a “kindly attitude” in your heart. Of course this turns Christianity into
nothing more than a nice religion of private piety—something that has been
regularly done throughout the centuries. But we should keep in mind that Jesus
was not crucified for teaching people to have a cheerful attitude. Jesus was
crucified for teaching there was another way to live than adhering to the
pharisaical religion of Israel or the brutal empire of Rome. It should be
obvious from an honest reading of the Gospels that Jesus expected His disciples
to master the lessons he taught and actually live a life centered on love and
forgiveness. And Jesus expects His modern-day followers to do the same—to
become disciples of love who master the art of forgiveness. Jesus was under no
illusion that this is an easy life.  In
His sermon He called it a narrow and difficult road, but He also called it the
road that leads to life.

The most common and vigorous
protest against any serious attempt to live the Sermon on the Mount is that
it’s not “practical.”

Not practical?  Practical is a very utilitarian (and at
times ugly) word. In this case, it is code for complicity with the status quo
and accepting the world as is as the only legitimate vision for
humanity. Before we can even try to live the Sermon on the Mount, we must first
experience the liberation of our imagination. If we only listen to the
“practical” men who run the world as it is, we will end up settling for the
anemic interpretation that the Sermon on the Mount is about private attitudes
of the heart and not about Jesus’ radical vision of love and forgiveness.

We must keep in mind that we
are told the Sermon on the Mount is not practical by those who have a deep
commitment to (and perhaps a vested interest in) perpetuating the status quo.
These practical men seek to control not only the way the world is run but even
our imaginations. They tell us, “This is just the way the real world works,”
and thus they seek to confine Jesus to a “heavenly” kingdom while they get on
with the practical business of running the “real” world. But the Holy Spirit is
a liberator of imagination, and we must reject the arrogant pretense of the
principalities and powers along with their bloody pragmatism. The church with a
Christ-inspired vision and a Holy Spirit-liberated imagination is to be that
realm where the followers of Jesus prove the practical men wrong by actually
living the Sermon on the Mount. To live the Sermon on the Mount, we first have
to rebel against the powers that be. We have to believe that there is another
way of being human.  We have to believe
that Jesus taught and modeled that way.

Continue reading below.

Watch Brian Zahnd discuss Unconditional?


The 20th century was one of the
bloodiest and most hate filled centuries in human history. It was a century
defined by war. As the children who were born at the close of World War II came
of age, they began to imagine an alternative to the hate and war that had
defined their parents’ generation, and so they sang and spoke of “love and
peace.” The problem was that no one could actually live it. As Larry Norman
wryly observed, “Beatles said all you need is love, and then they broke up.” The “love and peace” generation of the ’60s wasn’t wrong
in trying to imagine something better than a world filled with hate and war—it
was wrong in not finding a better messiah than the Beatles. Jesus didn’t just
talk about love and peace; He lived it to the extreme. When Jesus prayed
for His enemies to be forgiven as they drove the nails into His hands, He was
living His own sermon and validating His right to preach it.  After that, no one could dare claim that
Jesus’ teaching was not “practical.” Jesus had lived it, died for it, and been
vindicated by God in resurrection. His call is as vibrant and exciting today as
it was 2,000 years ago when He first issued it to Galilean fishermen: “Follow
Me.” It’s an invitation to follow Jesus in His radical way of enemy-love and
costly forgiveness.  If the only way of
responding to the evil of injustice is retaliation and revenge, we conspire
with the powers of darkness to keep the world an ugly place. This is why Jesus
(upon His own authority!) dared to countermand the Torah and alter the law of
“an eye for an eye and a tooth for a tooth” with His radical command not to
resist the one who is evil and to turn the other cheek. A world in which
tit-for-tat retaliation is the rule remains an ugly place where too many people
are missing an eye and a tooth. Or, as Mahatma Gandhi observed, “An eye for an
eye makes the whole world blind.” Jesus’ vision is to end the ugliness of
revenge and make the world beautiful through grace.  Grace is the distinctly Christian alternative to the tired system
of retaliation that perpetuates pain and leaves the whole world blind.

Grace is God’s idea of how the
world can be made new. Grace is why Jesus could call the poor and persecuted,
the mournful and meek, blessed. Jesus’ entire life and message were the
embodiment of the grace that triumphs over the cold pragmatism of a world where
the strong dominate the weak. Jesus’ message of love and forgiveness is not
rooted in a naïve optimism but in the grace that takes the blame, covers the
shame, and removes the stain and the endless cycle of revenge.  Grace is the antidote for the Eastern
concept of karma. Karma is the ancient idea that what goes around comes around,
and there is no escape from it, that retribution always has the final word.  But grace travels outside the rules of karma
and gives a different final word. Of course, the very basis of the Christian
gospel is that, because of what Christ accomplished on the cross, there is a
way for sinners to be saved from the destructive consequences (karma) of their
sins. But Christians are not just recipients of forgiving grace; we are also
called to be those who extend the grace of forgiveness to others. Christians
are to be carriers of grace in a world cursed with karma and endless cycles of

Grace is the great treasure of
the kingdom of God, or as Jesus described it in His parable, a pearl of great
price. That pearl is the gospel of the kingdom of heaven. It’s the pearl of the
gospel of grace that makes beauty out of ugly things. That’s what grace does.  Karma doesn’t have the final word, and the
ugliness of vengeance is not the final mark left upon humanity.

So, ultimately, for the
committed Christ follower, the question of forgiveness is not a question of
whether forgiveness is possible, but a question of how we can find the grace to
offer forgiveness.  We may discover that
we offer forgiveness to transgressors and offenders the same way that Jesus
did—amidst great suffering. In our feelings-oriented culture, it’s easy to
equate forgiveness with having certain feelings. Forgiveness is not a feeling.
Forgiveness is a choice to end the cycle of revenge and leave justice in the
hands of God. Very often we forgive our enemies by entering into the sufferings
of Christ who forgave from the cross. As Dietrich Bonhoeffer says in The
Cost of Discipleship
, “The call to follow Christ always means a call to
share the work of forgiving men their sins. Forgiveness is the Christ-like
suffering which it is the Christian’s duty to bear.” Dietrich Bonhoeffer was no starry-eyed idealist who
didn’t know about the reality of evil. He wrote these words during the rise of
Nazism in Germany and would eventually die at the hands of the Nazis.
Bonhoeffer’s theology of forgiveness was forged in the crucible of real and
costly suffering, but for Bonhoeffer, the cost of discipleship settled the
question of forgiveness.

 Click here to purchase
Brian Zahnd’s new book.

Leave a Comment

Scroll to Top
Copy link